The red meters scattered throughout downtown San Diego that collect donations for the homeless have raised nearly $10,000 since the first of nearly two dozen stations was installed four years ago.
While the total is far from enough money to help the city end its fight against homelessness, the nonprofit organization that operates the donation program says the meters are about more than generating money for homeless services.
“They were never meant to be a huge money-raiser,” said Kelly Knight, homeless outreach coordinator for the Downtown San Diego Partnership’s Clean & Safe program. “They were meant to be an awareness and an education tool.”
Next month marks four years since the Downtown San Diego Partnership installed the first donation meter. Since then, the nonprofit group has erected a total of 21 donation stations throughout downtown as part of its Make Change Count program.
The stations, which look like red parking meters and are located on private property, accept coin and credit card payments.
According to figures provided by the Downtown Partnership, meter donations have gradually increased each year. In fiscal 2012, the meters collected less than $1,000. In the last fiscal year, they generated more than $4,000.
Most of the money raised through the donation meters — roughly $6,500 — has gone toward a program called Work Your Way Home, which helps reunite homeless people with their family members. The rest of the money has been used to pay for credit card transaction fees associated with the donations and new donation meters.
Knight said the Work Your Way Home program helps identify family members who are able and willing to take in homeless relatives or loved ones struggling in San Diego. Once the connection is established, the program pays for their ticket home, she said.
“In exchange, we ask them to do a little work,” Knight said.
“That feature of the program is so important because it isn’t just moving folks out of the city and not caring about them,” said Dolores Diaz, executive director of the San Diego County Regional Task Force on the Homeless. “It is a compassionate way to reunify folks with some dignity.”
San Diego is one of several cities across the country that has installed donation meters for the homeless. Some programs have been more successful than others.
Supporters of the donation meters tout them as a way for people to contribute to organizations that know how to effectively care for the homeless. Critics argue that the meters are mainly used as a way to discourage panhandling and push the homeless out of downtown business districts.
“The whole idea is, don’t give money to poor people because if you do they’ll hang around,” said Paul Boden, executive director of the Western Regional Advocacy Project, a San Francisco-based organization that advocates for the homeless.
Boden said it’s upsetting that organizations in San Diego and other cities have spent so much time and resources installing donation meters. He said they haven’t generated much money and aren’t addressing the root causes of homelessness.
But Knight said the Downtown Partnership is encouraged by the success of its program. The nonprofit has plans to install 10 more meters downtown in the near future, she said.
Smart Cities
Higher Education
SMART TECH & IoT
Smart Parking is a critical facet of Smart Cities
TRUE INTEGRATION
All services connected to one backend system
CLOUD INFRASTRUCTURE
Computing capacity, flexibility, and scalability
HIGHER ED SMART PARKING
Comprehensive campus parking solutions
ENVIRONMENTAL SUSTAINABILITY
Paperless, solar power, upcycling, and more
DATA ANALYTICS
All you need to know from all your sources
4G LTE TECHNOLOGY
The fastest wireless connection on the market
Products & Solutions
SINGLE-SPACE METERS
Creators of the first smart Single-Space Parking Meter. Continual innovation ensures IPS meters are still unmatched…
MULTI-SPACE PAY STATIONS
Upgradeable, future-proof, and most flexible and comfortable user experience on the market…
ENFORCEMENT MANAGEMENT
Born in the cloud without issues that accompany old technologies, IPS provides flexible, scalable, and powerful enforcement solutions…
DATA MANAGEMENT SYSTEM
Measure user trends, drive demand-based pricing, and seamlessly integrate your entire parking network…
VEHICLE DETECTION SENSORS
Highly accurate, configurable to any parking environment and can be installed in minutes…
PAY STATION UPGRADE KITS
Save money, reduce waste, and maximize existing infrastructure by upgrading to the latest Smart Parking technology..
PERMIT MANAGEMENT
Full lifecycle permitting with custom customer-facing website to select, pay, and manage permits…
FULLY INTEGRATED SMART PARKING ECOSYSTEM
Apps and Services
PARK SMARTER™
Manage the parking experience on a smartphone
CONTACTLESS TECHNOLOGY
Convenient, secure, safe, and reliable
THIRD PARTY INTEGRATION
Streamline operations, improve efficiencies
IN-VEHICLE PAYMENT
Easiest way for drivers to pay for parking
MY PARKING RECEIPT™
Simplest way to manage parking expenses
PAYMENT PROCESSING
Saving IPS clients thousands of dollars per month
SMART COLLECTION
Access collection data anytime, anywhere
Resources
BROCHURES
Read about our Apps & Services, Infographics, Products & Solutions, and Quick Guides…
CASE STUDIES
Real cities, agencies, colleges and universities – real success stories…
VIDEOS
Got a minute? Short IPS videos will change the way you see parking…
FAQs
Quick answers to common questions…
Newsroom
NEWS
When IPS hits local and national news…
BLOG
The latest smart parking updates…
PRESS RELEASES
What’s new and coming soon for IPS Group…